E-LOGOS - University of Economics, Prague
Faculty of Economics, University of Economics, Prague

Impure Infinitism and the Evil Demon Argument (2016)

Author: H. Inusah

Email: huseinusa@gmail.com

Affiliation: Department of Classics and Philosophy, University of Cape Coast, Ghana

Department of Classics and Philosophy
University of Cape Coast
Cape Coast

Article type: Standard scientific article

Section: History of Philosophy

Language: language

Abstract (english):

The central thesis of this paper is that the modus ponens reductio argument does not clearly favour impure versions of infinitism. The nub of the modus ponens reductio argument is as follows: an infinite series of justified reasons by itself is vulnerable to the modus ponens reductio in the sense that one can construct an infinite chain of reasons supporting both an affirmative and denial of proposition, say p. The problem here is that, as Aikin urges, pure versions of infinitism do not possess the requisite resource to eliminate one of these chains of infinite reasons. The upshot is that pure versions of infinitism are not able to differentiate between an infinite series that is truth conducive and the ones that are not. Accordingly, Aikin promotes an impure infinitism over pure infinitism because, as he opines, impure infinitism has the requisite resources to eliminate one of the infinite chains of justified reasons and rids itself of the threat of the modus ponens reductio. In the following discussion, I submit that although Aikin seems quite successful in this venture, his version of impure infinitism faces a similar setback, in the form of the new evil demon problem, which is equally fatal to it as that which the modus ponens reductio wrecks on pure versions of infinitism.

Download/View: 23_02_inusah.pdf

Current issue

Next issue will be published in August 2017.

Indexed by

E-LOGOS was licensed as peer-reviewed scientific journal by the Research and Development Council of the Government of the Czech Republic.

E-LOGOS is indexed in ERIH Plus.