E-LOGOS - University of Economics, Prague
Faculty of Economics, University of Economics, Prague

Reason and Nature: McDowell, Kant and Peacocke on Perception (2009)

Author: O. R. Calle

Email: olgaramirezcalle@gmail.com

Affiliation: Department of Humanities and the Arts, University of Saint Louis Missouri, Campus Madrid

Department of Humanities and the Arts
University of Saint Louis Missouri
Campus Madrid
28003 Madrid

Article type: Standard scientific article

Section: Epistemology

Language: language

Abstract (english):

The paper contrasts to completely different approaches on the relations of reason and nature: the one assumed in the context of the studies on ‘bounded rationality’ and the one proposed in McDowell’s Mind and World. As a result of this contrast two different models of the relation of reason and nature appear: what may be called respectively a top-down and a botton-up model. Drawing on Kant’s own proposals in his ‘Schematism of Pure Reason’ I will develop some criticism of McDowell’s bottom up approach, defending the need of a normative non-conceptual level on which basis the conceptual would be developed. I will draw some connections between these proposal and some suggestions made by Peacocke, arguing finally that the resulting position would seem to be compatible with the bounded rationality approach.

Download/View: calle09.pdf

Current issue

Next issue will be published in August 2019.

Indexed by

E-LOGOS was licensed as peer-reviewed scientific journal by the Research and Development Council of the Government of the Czech Republic.

E-LOGOS is indexed in ERIH Plus.