Je Methodenstreit minulostí?
Keywords: rationalism, methodology, economics, positivism, Austrian school of economics
In the first part, and on the general level, the article defends the methodological dualism of rationalism against much more fashionable methodological monism of empiricism-positivism, and shows why the latter must be considered self-contradictory and thus fallacious.
In the second part, applying the rationalist position in the field of economics, it shows that economics, its subject of inquiry being action of man, should use a deductive method to arrive at apodictically true propositions. Since, on the contrary, the current mainstream economics uses almost exclusively (but fallaciously) the positivist (inductive) method, the article evaluates the negative consequences of doing so upon the fields of both theoretical economics and economic policy.
Prepublished online: January 1, 2001; Published: June 1, 2001 Show citation
References
- Martin Čihák (ed.): Ekonomie jako imperiální věda (sborník k 15. semináři ČSE v řadě "Ekonomická teorie a česká ekonomika), ČSE, Praha, 1999.
- Nicholas Dykes: A Tangled Web of Guesses: A Critical Assessment of the Philosophy of Karl Popper, Philosophical Notes 37, Libertarian Alliance, Londýn, 1996.
- Bruno Frey, et al: "Consensus and dissension among economists: an empirical inquiry" v American Economic Review, č. 5, 1984, str. 986-94.
- Milton Friedman: Metodologie pozitivní ekonomie, Liberální institut, Praha, 1997.
- Hans-Hermann Hoppe: Economic Science and the Austrian Method, Ludwig von Mises Institute, Auburn (AL), 1995.
- Hans-Hermann Hoppe: "On Certainty and Uncertainty, Or: How Rational Can Our Expectations Be?" v Review of Austrian Economics, sv. X, č. 1, 1997, str. 49-78.
Go to original source...
- Hans-Hermann Hoppe: "In Defence of Extreme Rationalism: Thoughts on Donald McCloskey's The Rhetoric of Economics" v Review of Austrian Economics, sv. III, 1989, str. 179-214.
Go to original source...
- Hans-Hermann Hoppe: "The Western State as a Paradigm: Learning from History" v Politics & Regimes, sv. 30, 1997, str. 1-26.
- Ludwig von Mises: Epistemological Problems of Economics, NYU Press. New York, 1981.
- Ludwig von Mises: Human Action: A Treatise on Economics, Fox & Wilkes, San Francisco, 1963.
- Ludwig von Mises: Theory and History, Ludwig Mises Institute, Auburn, 1985.
- Ludwig von Mises: The Ultimate Foundation of Economic Science, D. Van Nostrand, 1962.
- Murray N. Rothbard: Man, Economy, and State, Ludwig von Mises Institute, Auburn (AL), 1993.
- Murray N. Rothbard: Economic Thought Before Adam Smith, Edward Elgar Publishing Company, Brookfield (VT), 1995.
- Murray N. Rothbard: "Praxeology: A Reply to Mr Schuller" v American Economic Review, prosinec 1951, str. 943-946.
- Murray N. Rothbard: "The Mantle of Science" v Murray N. Rothbard: Logic of Action One, Edward Elgar Publishing Company, Brookfield (VT), 1997, str. 3-23.
- Murray N. Rothbard: "What is the Proper Way to Study Man?" v ibid., str. 24-27.
- Murray N. Rothbard: "Praxeology as the Method of Social Sciences" v ibid., str. 28-57.
- Murray N. Rothbard: "Praxeology: The Methodology of Austrian Economics" v ibid., str. 58-77.
- Murray N. Rothbard: "In Defense of 'Extreme Apriorism'" v ibid., str. 100-108.
- Murray N. Rothbard: "The Hermeneutical Invasion of Philosophy and Economics" v Murray N. Rothbard: Logic of Action Two, Edward Elgar Publishing Company, Brookfield (VT), 1997, str. 275-293.
- Murray N. Rothbard: "Intimidation by Rhetoric" v Review of Austrian Economics, sv. IX, č. 1, 1996, str. 173-180.
Go to original source...
- George A. Selgin: "Praxeology and Understanding: An Analysis of the Controversy in Austrian Economics" v Review of Austrian Economics, sv. II, 1988, str. 19-58.
Go to original source...
- Jesus Huerta de Soto: "The Ongoing Methodenstreit of the Austrian School" v Journal des Economistes et des Etudes Humaines, sv. VIII, č. 1, březen 1998, str. 75-113.
Go to original source...
- George J. Stigler: Essays in the History of Economics, The University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 1965.
- Josef Šíma: "Rozvíjející se rakouská tradice: Od metodologického individualismu k hodnocení hospodářských politik" v Martin Čihák (ed.): Rakouská škola a její význam pro současnost: Pohled na trh jako proces (sborník k 7. semináři ČSE v řadě "Ekonomické teorie a česká ekonomika), ČSE, Praha, 1999.